Short answer: In the caustic scouring bath, AOS 92% keeps its wetting speed where LAS drops out as calcium soap, and it survives the alkali without hydrolyzing. The cost per kilogram of fabric differs by well under one cent, so the choice usually comes down to water hardness and machine foam tolerance, not price.
This comparison is written for textile mills and chemical suppliers building or re-sourcing the scouring auxiliaries package for cotton and cotton blends. Our customers run these markets: India, Pakistan, Iran, Russia and Southeast Asia. We sell AOS 92%, AOS 95%, AOS 35% and AOS 38%. LAS (CAS 68411-30-3) is the market benchmark and is not part of our range. Test values and prices below are illustrative working numbers.
What does the scouring bath have to do?
Scouring removes the cotton wax, pectin and seed-coat fragments that survive desizing, so that dye liquor can reach the fiber evenly later. The typical bath is 5 to 15 g/L sodium hydroxide at 95°C for 30 to 60 minutes, with a wetting agent at 0.3 to 1.0 g/L and sometimes a detergent builder. Two failure modes decide whether the auxiliary works: the bath stops wetting the fabric, or the machine fouls with deposited soap. Both are water-hardness problems, and they hit LAS before they hit AOS.
AOS vs LAS in the caustic bath: what do the wetting numbers show?
Illustrative screen at 0.5 g/L active in 10 g/L NaOH, tested at 95°C and at 60°C in 150 and 400 mg/kg CaCO3 water. Wetting time is the Draves skein test; lower is better.
| Surfactant at 0.5 g/L | 95°C, 150 mg/kg | 95°C, 400 mg/kg | 60°C, 150 mg/kg | 60°C, 400 mg/kg | Bath appearance at 400 mg/kg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AOS 92% | 8 s | 11 s | 15 s | 19 s | Clear |
| LAS 96% | 10 s | 52 s | 18 s | Over 120 s | Cloudy, scum on the wall |
In soft water the two run close, with LAS slightly ahead at 95°C. In hard water the gap opens fast: calcium LAS is sparingly soluble and comes out of solution as a sticky soap that deposits on fabric and on heater surfaces. Over months of hot washes that shows up as uneven dyeing and as scale on the heating coil. AOS is a sulfonate, so its calcium salt stays in solution; the wetting time at 400 mg/kg is close to the soft-water figure at both temperatures.
Which machines tolerate which foam?
Foam splits the decision by machine type. AOS builds a tall, stable foam; LAS in hard water foams poorly, which operators misread as a strong bath. Jet dyeing machines and some overflow machines run with high mechanical agitation and want low foam, because foam blankets the fabric and gives uneven treatment. For those machines, run AOS at the low end of its dose window, 0.3 to 0.5 g/L, or accept a defoamer in the package. Winch becks and open-width scouring ranges tolerate the foam without trouble, and the foam there helps carry the removed wax into the bath instead of redepositing on the cloth. Our foam height versus concentration data shows the shape of the curve for the common anionics.
What does the scouring auxiliary cost per kilogram of fabric?
Worked example, illustrative. An open-width scouring range at a 1:5 liquor ratio treats 1 kg of fabric with 5 L of bath. At 0.5 g/L active, that is 2.5 g of active surfactant per kilogram of fabric.
| Surfactant | Active per kg of fabric | Illustrative price per tonne of active | Cost per kg of fabric |
|---|---|---|---|
| AOS 92% | 2.5 g | 1,750 USD | 0.44 US cents |
| AOS 95% | 2.5 g | 1,900 USD | 0.48 US cents |
| LAS 96% | 2.5 g | 1,400 USD | 0.35 US cents |
At soft water the LAS line is about 0.09 US cents per kilogram of fabric cheaper. At 400 mg/kg CaCO3 that saving disappears, because the hard-water LAS bath needs a higher dose to hold the same wetting time, and the mill pays again for coil descaling and for re-scouring lots that dyed patchy. The real comparison is the cost per acceptable meter, not the cost per gram of surfactant.
Which grade fits a scouring package?
Powder concentrates and dry blends take AOS 92% directly; it disperses in the bath at 95°C without a pre-mix tank. AOS 95% is for low-dose liquid concentrates where freight per kilogram of active dominates, with a bulk density of 0.3 to 0.4 g/cm3 that keeps bag handling light. Liquid dosing systems take AOS 38% or AOS 35% by pump; AOS 38% is the usual pick because it needs 8% less product per dose than AOS 35% at the same active matter. Mills in soft-water regions sometimes substitute SLES 70% paste for the wetting line, which is cheaper per kilogram of active but foams higher and needs heated storage in winter. Where the package also wants a sulfate-ester wetting kick for the cold pad-batch step, SLS 92% at 0.2 to 0.3 g/L lifts cold wetting, and the wetting time comparison puts it in context against AOS and SLES.
Key takeaways
- Hard water decides it: AOS 92% holds about 11 s wetting at 400 mg/kg CaCO3 where LAS 96% runs past 52 s and clouds the bath.
- Alkali is not the problem: both surfactants survive 10 g/L NaOH at 95°C; calcium solubility is what removes LAS from the bath.
- Cost per kg of fabric is small either way: 0.44 US cents for AOS 92% against 0.35 US cents for LAS 96% at 0.5 g/L, illustrative.
- Match foam to the machine: jet machines want the low end of the AOS dose, winch becks and open ranges tolerate it.
- Grade by form: AOS 92% powder for concentrates, AOS 38% liquid for pumped dosing systems, AOS 95% for low-dose concentrates.
Frequently asked questions
Can I run AOS in a jet dyeing machine without a defoamer?
Sometimes. Start at 0.3 g/L and watch the first two lots; if the foam blanket marks the fabric, drop to 0.2 g/L or add a defoamer to the package. Jet machines vary widely in liquor circulation, and a bath that foams over in one machine runs clean in another at the same dose.
Does AOS affect the final dye shade?
A properly scoured bath should leave no residual surfactant that competes for dye. Rinse after scouring as usual and check the last rinse pH; a bath that ran rich in AOS and was under-rinsed can shift anionic dye uptake slightly. The effect is smaller than the patchy-dyeing risk of an under-scoured lot.
What water hardness should I design for?
Measure at the machine, not the plant gate. Well water in many mills across India, Pakistan and Iran swings between 150 and 600 mg/kg CaCO3 with the season. Design the auxiliary dose for the high end; the formula only runs rich in the soft months.
Is AOS stable in a cold pad-batch bath?
Yes, at the pH range of a caustic pad bath it stays in solution and keeps wetting. Cold wetting is slower than hot wetting for every anionic, which is why pad-batch recipes hold a dwell time rather than a wetting-time spec. If the cold step is the bottleneck, a small SLS 92% addition lifts cold wetting faster than raising the AOS dose.
How do I switch a running recipe from LAS to AOS?
Start at equal active grams per liter, then run three lots side by side with whiteness, wettability and dye patchiness as the acceptance tests. Expect to trim the dose down once the bath stops throwing soap scum, because AOS wets at a lower effective concentration once it is not being consumed by calcium.
Request a quote or a sample
For bulk pricing, MOQ and lead time on AOS 92%, AOS 95%, AOS 38% or AOS 35%, request a quote with your destination port and annual volume. If you are switching a scouring recipe, request a sample of both powder grades and run the three-lot trial on your hardest water. You can request the COA and MSDS for either grade before you commit, or contact our team with your liquor ratio, caustic level and water hardness and we will check the dose arithmetic against your recipe.
Written and reviewed by the ORID Chem technical team. Last updated: 15 November 2026. Prices, dose figures and test values in this article are illustrative working numbers, not quotations. Confirm current specifications on the product TDS and lot COA before ordering.



